Thursday, April 21, 2011

Essay 4.1: There's a Future for Foster Kids

When I met my first foster sibling, Summer, I realized the importance of my role in her life. I was someone she could look up to and that came to mean so much to me. Being the youngest in my family, I had always wanted a younger sibling, but Summer quickly became much more than that. Knowing that an 8-year-old girl can emerge resilient and even optimistic coming from the abusive life she faced is truly inspiring. Frankly, I was taken aback by our first interaction. I tried to be open minded, but I was very skeptical after observing her that day. She did not act the way I would expect a “normal” 8-year-old to act. She was unaware of the food smeared on her face and seemed disinterested in touring the house, but rather more interested in keeping her box of cookies safe, which she clenched so tightly that her knuckles began to turn white. I had never met anyone so outside the realm of what I believed to be was normal. I doubted that living in our home would be able to benefit her in any way, but I was wrong.

As I got to know Summer, I realized that she is one of the sweetest, kindest people I have met. She wants what everyone wants- love and stability. Unfortunately, Summer never saw those basic foundations of family from her original home. As I heard more and more about where she came from and the struggles she inevitably had yet to face in life, my heart broke. I learned so much from Summer and she has grown so much since entering my house. In just a few months, she was transferred out of her remedial classroom. She became more trusting and every time my mom left the house, the look of terror on her face came less and less often; Unlike her biological mom, she knew mine would always return. Most importantly, she realized that when her mom willingly gave up her parental rights, the hope for a family didn’t end; instead the likeliness of this hope grew when she saw that her mother’s abandonment actually set her free from an unfair life of abuse and neglect.





Family is one of the most significant factors in shaping a child’s future. Through establishing close relationships with my many foster siblings over the past few years, I have seen the true importance of family in one’s life. For those children who come from abusive and destructive families, the influence of healthy familial relationships is life-changing.

In the spring of 2006 my mother decided to become a foster parent. At the time I was not sure what this would truly mean for the kids who would enter my home; and I did not even contemplate the influence each child would have on my own life. As a foster parent, one provides the physical and emotional care a child needs after he or she separated from the biological family for whatever reason. The main idea of foster parenting is that it is a temporary situation (which can last from a few days to a few years) until ultimately the child can reunite with their family after conflicts are resolved, or until a child gets adopted (National). The main goal is to provide a child with a sense of care and security that they undeniably deserve.

My mom became affiliated with what is called a therapeutic foster care agency, meaning that the children who were under their care were troubled, to say the least. The likeliness of any of them getting adopted was very small. Many faced depression or bipolar disorder and came from families with extremely abusive family members and very dangerous living situations. Most of them were abandoned and/or abused by their biological parents or relatives. It's hard to live a normal life after once being subjected to such an unjust childhood. It’s impossible to ignore the suffering they must have endured in such unfair family situations, but our goal became to show these kids that they deserve much more.
Unfortunately, according to Enhanced Services and Stipends for Foster Parents: Effects on Retention Rates and Outcomes for Children, “While the availability of foster homes is shrinking… more children and adolescents who have more complex problems are entering the system” (Chamberlain, 388). Although more is being done to improve the lives of foster children, there are many that do not get placed in a home and never get to experience any form of stability in life. Thanks to the Chaffee Foster Care to Independence Act, the futures for foster children are looking better (Foster Care). However, the shortage of foster parents is truly detrimental to the cause. The presence of a loving home and family in a neglected child's life is indispensable when it comes to working to better the life of a foster child. Before building irreplaceable relationships with my foster siblings, I was not aware of what an inrrevocalbe influence a foster family could have on a foster child's life, and vice versa.


It was in the summer of 2007 when I met Charlie Gilleo. He would be my second foster sibling and my first foster brother. His story has been the most moving and has helped me to realize the true importance of foster parenting. Without the support and love from my family, I honestly don’t know where he would be today. He came into my home when he was 13 years old. The first time I saw him he was wearing a dirtied white tank top, jeans that were too big for him and a gold chain. He talked quietly and used very few words. He seemed guarded, yet polite; the few words he did mutter were “thank you” and “please”. I was a little worried about this new foster sibling. I knew we wouldn’t have an immediate connection like I did with Summer. The one thing I noticed about him in the first week of living with us is his thankfulness. His courtesy was actually surprising. I understand now why he was so afraid of making mistakes and seeming unappreciative; he came from a home where any small mistake would end in him being beaten. After a few weeks, I was pleasantly surprised when Charlie began to loosen up. What he would soon endure, however, would be a test of not only his own strength, but of the strength of my family in supporting him through what may be the hardest time he will ever face in his life.

Charlie never really had a relationship with his father. He would send him birthday cards, make a day visit every so often, but his father’s main concern in life was when he would be able to shoot up with heroin next. Growing up, Charlie lived with his drug-addicted mother and his younger half-siblings, all from different fathers. One thing I have noticed about foster kids is that they hold onto the family they have left and want so desperately to forgive and forget the mistakes of the family members who have abused them. I think that part of this innate forgiveness comes from the desire to just be a normal kid and live with their biological family without any complications of foster parents, social workers, supervised visits with family, and so on. They think they can work past the struggles of abuse and neglect, but they don’t know that they deserve so much better. When Charlie heard that his father got arrested and was being tried for murder in the first degree, he flew off the handle. I was puzzled that he cared so much about a man who was never really there. To say Charlie had an anger problem would be an understatement as he was being treated for bipolar disorder. 

The arrest of Charlie’s father was a major story in my town. Given the fact that Charlie was named after his father, the name "Charlie Gilleo," which was synonymous in my town for murder, was not only connected to Charlie Gilleo Sr, (his father) but also Charlie Gilleo Jr (my foster brother). Everyone in school knew about his father. And worse for him, everyone in school believed in his father's guilt. The weeks leading up to Charlie's dad's trial were tense to say the least. We all had to watch what we said around the house. Understandably, it was a sensitive and tense time for Charlie. I wished I knew what advice to give to him. But it’s hard to relate to someone whose father he hoped he would once be able to live with may be sentenced to life in prison. In my experience, most foster children hold onto the hope that they will one day be able to live with their family again, and this will somehow make them feel whole. But with this arrest, that hope was completely crushed for Charlie. His dad's name was in the paper every day. Thankfully, Charlie was a big kid for his age so no one said anything hurtful to his face about his father. His intimidating demeanor kept him safe from explicit mocking. However, what may have hurt even more to Charlie was the inevitable whispering when he walked to the halls and the silence he endured when he entered a room, fully aware they were just talking about his father.

At the time of the trial, my mom and I were driving in the car on our way home. It was then when my mom got the call: Charlie's dad was found guilty for murder. Charlie's father's guilt or innocence was beside the point that this was the news she dreaded haring. She knew this would change Charlie forever; this would shatter him and nothing would ever be able to fully put him back together. My mom then pressed on the gas a little more and sped home, knowing the situation we would walk into would not be pretty. We had been working through Charlie’s temper problem, but this verdict would send all of that progress down the drain. When we entered the house we saw two holes in the wall, broken glass, and drips of blood on the floor. My sister looked baffled and didn’t know what to do. Her only words, "He locked himself in the bathroom and won't come out." I was afraid. I was afraid of what this damage of the holes in the wall and broken glass meant for him- a reflection of the damage inside himself. My mom begged Charlie to open up the door but didn't hear anything. We both thought the worst and were overcome with panic. Finally after anxiously pounding on the door for five more minutes, Charlie opened the door, looked my mom in the eyes, and fell into her arms sobbing. He had broken his hand that night from punching in the wall so we had to take him to the emergency room. A cast fixed his hand, but wouldn't come even close to fixing the damage he would endure from this verdict.

It took a while for Charlie to be able to work through this. It breaks my heart when I think of how unfair it is that a child has to go through this. Charlie did nothing wrong. Yet, he paid for the neglectful and abusive acts of his parents. I don’t know if I would ever have the strength to face Charlie’s challenges and still persevere. We have been there for him like a real family. I like to think that we have filled a missing part of Charlie’s life; and Charlie, among my other foster siblings have filled a hole in my life that I didn’t even know existed. Charlie was lucky enough to have a strong, faithful support system there for him at such a tough time in his life. No child should have to face such challenges alone. What is so discouraging is that there are so many foster children out there not living in foster homes. They may not know what it is really like to be in a healthy family, and that scares me for their future.

The presence of a foster family in an abandoned and abused child’s life can give them a better future. These children can now feel a sense of safety and security. Often, many of these kids are ill-clothed, malnourished, and have rarely ever been to the doctor. Placement in a foster home guarantees that these vital physical necessities be met. They can focus on being kids; they don’t need to worry about hiding from abuse, if they have a place to sleep, food to eat, and so on. Foster care provides children with the opportunity to experience things they never got to do in their original home such as going on trips, vacations, joining a club, and most importantly being part of a loving family. Foster care gives children the chance to live a life full of satisfaction and happiness they are justified to.

16 comments:

  1. Molly,

    I really enjoyed reading your narrative argument, “There’s a Future for Foster Kids”. I was really interested and intrigued by the information you provided about Foster Parenting. I think it is a great thing that you and your family do.

    I liked the background information that you gave about foster parenting. I think that it was good that you did provide the information and statistics about how majority kids come out of the foster home with problems than they had before.

    I think you did a great job in portraying to the reader the emotions these foster children have, because they do have hard lives and reading this paper just make you appreciate the life that you have.

    Your paper is rather long. When I was reading it in the beginning, I wanted to know more background information on Summer, but then I realized that most of your detail and focus was on Charlie. So maybe you could have your entire paper on Charlie’s story (since it is very good ad interesting) and leave out Summer’s story it could keep your paper more focused. I think if you spread your research out more that would be great too.

    I think your rough draft is great and I loved reading your family story. I hope my suggestions help you and good luck with your revision!

    -Becca Moran

    ReplyDelete
  2. Molly,

    I enjoyed reading your first draft of you narrative argument as it is a very powerful subject, both emotionally and with the point. I think you used the narrative effectively to introduce the subject matter and although there is more narrative than argument, I think in this case it works in your favor. You have many powerful statements incorporated in your paper that I picked up on; examples such as in the middle of the 2nd paragraph beginning with “She was unaware…” and in the 8th paragraph starting with “One thing…” I think these really help bring across the point you are trying to make and it adds even more when it comes from your personally (meaning you learned or observed something).

    Your introduction was engaging and I wanted to know more at the end of it. I just wasn’t sure if that narrative except was particularly necessary. I understand the connection you felt with Summer might not have been what you had with Charlie, but it was only used in the beginning. I would consider starting the paper with the introduction of Charlie or some other catchy anecdote about your experiences with him; then continue the story with his father later on in the paper. I just think that one narrative with more in depth insight could be more effective.

    I really liked the sources used in the 6th paragraph but I felt that you could expand more in between quotes. Or at least spread them out more because there is not another source used after that paragraph. You might be able to find a source and incorporate it in the 5th paragraph; something about the importance of family. If you do find a relevant source, I would think about moving that whole paragraph towards the end as it is very effective and wraps up your point nicely. Your conclusion does this as well; your ending sentences really show what you proved in the paper.

    Overall, I think you have a great first draft and with a few revisions from the feedback of your classmates, you will be on your way to an even better narrative argument. Good luck with your revisions!

    --Ethan Freedman

    ReplyDelete
  3. Dear Molly,

    Wow. Your narrative was incredibly touching. I think caring for foster children is one of the most important things for people to do, and the fact that you have such personal and emotional stories really makes your argument great.

    In the end, I was so amazed by Charlie's story that I realized that I had sort of forgotten about Summer's. I don't think you should eliminate her story, but I think you should either shorten it to make it seem like more like a warm-up to Charlie's, or build on it more in ways to make it as captivating as Charlie's. The beginning of your essay also felt a little rushed. It's hard to describe what I felt exactly, but I think Summer's story was on fast-forward, and it disappeared quickly.

    Other than that, you have an excellent essay here. Your use of pathos is the strongest I've seen. Good luck on your revision, I'm sure it will come out well!

    - Greg

    ReplyDelete
  4. Molly,

    Your narrative was very powerful and moving. I cannot even begin to imagine what that experience must have been like in person, living with many foster siblings. That is a very admirable task and commitment for your family and yourself to take on, and I very much enjoyed reading about your experience. The stories of your foster siblings' lives are heartbreaking, but its so good to know there are families such as your own to help out these kids and provide them a better, more loving life and support system.

    I do not want to say that the story of Charlie and his father is not important because it definitely is. I think this was a very powerful portion of your narrative, however I think that this story begins to dominate your essay by the end, and we sort of forget about Summer. I would like to learn a little bit more about specific examples of what it was like living with Summer, especially because she was your first foster sibling.

    I think it would also benefit your argument overall to add more detail from other sources about the benefits and importance of foster care - possibly by including some statistics or testimonies from kids who have been through foster care?

    Your paper was rather long, but the writing was very clear and easy to read and it flowed very smoothly. I think that in order to make it flow even better though, you could break up and shorten some of your sentences a bit. Your writing is great but you tend to write in very long, drawn out sentences. This is just something to be careful of.

    In general, the main thing I would suggest working on is making sure your focus in your paper stays around the importance of foster care, and not the struggles that Charlie faced. I say this only because by the end, I had forgotten your main argument a little.

    One last thing I am curious about, but you do not necessarily need to include this in your paper, is if you are still in touch with Summer and Charlie now that you are in college? Do they still live with your family? This is more for my own curiosity but these details could help strengthen your paper!

    Good job with your first draft and good luck with your revisions!

    -Meredith

    ReplyDelete
  5. Molly,

    I think you chose a very good, emotional, interesting topic for your paper, and because of this, I enjoyed reading your paper a lot. I learned a lot!

    I liked your intro, bringing in Summer was a good decision because it got me interested. You told a lot of stories, but I wish you would have gone more in-depth with them. Show, don't tell. You did this with the first sentence about Summer in the intro. and a little throughout the rest, but I just wanted more details; I was so interested and curious.

    Also, your paper is very informative, but I didn't know who the "enemy" was or what the claim was because I felt like you never clearly stated that. I think doing these things would help give your paper more of the argumentative edge that it needs.

    Lastly, I really liked the suspense you used in your 7th paragraph. It was really good.

    Good job so far!
    Lindsay Beatty

    ReplyDelete
  6. Molly,

    Wonderful job on your first draft. Your story fostered great pathos, and made the paper very interesting and fascinating. I think it’s wonderful that your family does this, and I commend and admire you and your parents for it.

    One thing I’d suggest is more emphasis and balance between the stories. Just to make it flow better, make sure you provide specific examples to illustrate key things you’d like to get across to the audience. Likewise, make sure you focus on the big picture, or point of the paper—the importance and need for foster care, and the gratification it brings to families, rather than Charlie’s story specifically. Charlie’s story is important, just try to incorporate this theme throughout the essay in small doses to remind the reader of the message.

    Other than these small details, wonderful first draft. Good luck on your revision!

    -Ethan Wennberg

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hey Molly,

    Firstly, I would like to thank you for sharing such an personal story with us. It is wonderful how your family is so commited to such a cause that society barely gives much attention to.

    Because of your involvement in the subject, you have definitely established much credibility as an author. You have great story telling techniques, I especially enjoyed the little details you mention e.g. "keeping her cookies safe, which she clenched so tightly that her knuckles began to turn white"..even though they are little details, they had a great impact on me as a reader.

    I think you have good sources, however, I feel that the essay needs more balance as currently your narratives are overshadowing your claims, so maybe cut down on the story telling and ponder more on your argument.

    I wish you well on your final draft!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Molly,

    I thought you did a nice job with your first draft. I thought your story was very unique and very powerful. I thought you wrote with simple language and it made me really appreciate what you and your family does.

    The only problem that I have with your paper is the fact that you save the reason you are writing your essay for the end. I thought if you integrate your purpose throughout your whole paper, it would be better.

    Good luck on your revisions.

    Greg Bloom

    ReplyDelete
  9. Molly,

    I really enjoyed reading your paper. What a wonderful and powerful topic you chose! Your story is intriguing from beginning to end. You apply pathos extremely well and I stay attached to the experience the entire essay. You have an effective use of detail and you keep the reader interested throughout. You effectively build suspense in regards to Charlies situation and I too became worried about him.

    With that said, in the 9th paragraph you seem to repeat yourself. "But with this arrest..." sentence and the following one, you became a little redundant. I understand you want to convey the trauma of the situation, but you have already established it extremely effectively.

    Its a great narrative piece but I also feel that it may be too narrative heavy? I would suggest finding statistics on child abuse to strengthen your claim. Stats are powerful. I would also be interested to see may be a quote from one of the foster children your family has helped if at all possible.

    Other than that this is a very passionate and intriguing paper. Good Job and good luck!

    Molly Schneider

    ReplyDelete
  10. Molly,

    This was quite a powerful paper, I think this a really appropriate subject for this type of argument. I thought it was a really thoughtful, moving and unique piece.
    I really liked both stories about Summer and Charlie, It seems though that the story about Summer kind of gets lost. I think this might be because Charlie's story is so strong, I wonder if you could bring Summer into the rest of the paper more maybe by comparing Charlie's and Summer's pasts, and their reactions to living in a new home.
    Overall great essay
    Good luck with revisions
    Zane

    ReplyDelete
  11. Molly,

    I thought your argument was extremely interesting and moving. It went really in depth with your life and you really brought out your own personality and character. Your story is so unique that is grabbed my attention right from the beginning.

    While I was reading, it made me very sad hearing about your foster siblings' lives, but it made me happy knowing that your family's love is really helping these people. Your story was very honorable.

    Here are a few things to work on:

    In your introduction, you begin talking about your foster sister, Summer. However, towards the end of your argument, I began to realize that her story is lost and I wanted to know more about your connection with her. I think your biggest problem with your essay is finding its focus.

    I think if you either choice a focus between Summer or Charlie, it would be easier to read and more effective. If you are going to write about Charlie for the majority of your paper, then you should mention him more than Summer in your introduction. This will help the reader know what he or she is going to read about and what your focus is.

    Even though your second paragraph is very moving and Summer is very important to you, but maybe that paragraph is a bit unnecessary if your focus is on Charlie? Maybe you can briefly mention Summer, but put Charlie more in the first and second paragraph.

    I also felt that your argument was a little bit too narrative based. You should add more sources and information to back up your argument. Maybe you can find a story about someone else on the internet. Even though you have a lot of credibility as a writer because of your personal experiences, it would be good to hear a different perspective.

    Good luck on your revisions!
    -Joni Fromer

    ReplyDelete
  12. Molly,

    I really found your topic interesting and very unique. I liked the fact you really tried to hit the readers emotions, and gave great detail as to the feelings of a child and parenting. Keep all of the detail because it only adds to the support for your story.

    Things to look out for could be your narratives overpowering each other and your point. At some points in the narratives, such as Charles, I began to drift away from the rest of the paper because I was so engaged in it.

    Overall nice job and good luck!

    Jake

    ReplyDelete
  13. -Molly
    I really enjoyed reading your paper! It was by far one of the most emotionally powerful because of Summer and Charlie's stories and the work your family does. Both stories were very touching but, I feel like Summers story becomes over shadowed by Charlie's. Overall your paper was very strong even though your claim is clear because it comes at the end of the paper the stories are not as strong as they could be. Maybe introduce it a little in the beginning and then in the end talk about summer again, so both are constant throughout.
    Great first draft and good luck!
    -Chloe

    ReplyDelete
  14. Molly,

    I really liked your narrative, very moving. The experiances you put into the story were very powerful and emotional so nice job on that aspect.

    Overall really strong essay. I did not exect a topic like this to be written about, but you did a nice job getting your message across.

    I would suggest to not skip on details, do not worry about making it too long. The details will only make it easier to read.

    Other than that good luck with your revision,

    -Dan Sheldon

    ReplyDelete
  15. Molly,
    It was great to read your essay! What your family does it inspirational and your essay was very touching to read! Your personal story is a very unique one which makes this story so great because it could only be written by you. The depth and detail you go into really allows the reader to connect and understand your story.

    The story of Charlie and his father is heartbreaking and is a story in which can be used to portray a powerful message, but I feel as though you are going after the wrong message.

    I feel that if you want to explain the importance of a foster family through this experience, you should go into further detail into how being in a foster family has helped Charlie in the difficult situation he was put into. Without a clear understanding of that, the point of the story with in the essay is lost.

    Great first draft!! Keep it up

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hey Molly,

    I really enjoyed this essay! It was amazing to see how you took such a personal issue and drew awareness about an even bigger issue. It was so passionate and effective!

    I wanted to know what happened to Summer. Does she still live with your family like Charlie or was she later adopted? Nice incorporation of sources I felt like everything flowed really well together. In the paragraph where you told us about finding out that Charlies father was guilty, I think you should indent the sentence "When we entered the house" into a new paragraph. I feel like that's one of the climax scenes in your story and I think it would pop more if it were a new paragraph.

    Great narrative and good job addressing an issue not a lot of people know about. Good luck with revisions!
    -Christina

    ReplyDelete